Minutes
Board of Trustees
Middletown Thrall Library
The Minutes for 10 / 7 / 2026
MINUTES OF THE MEETING
THRALL PUBLIC LIBRARY DISTRICT OF MIDDLETOWN AND WALLKILL BOARD OF TRUSTEES
October 7, 2026
I. Attendance/Pledge of Allegiance
Ms. Russell called the roll
Present
Ms. Evelyn Ortega, Vice President
Ms. Narene Russell, Secretary
Mrs. Susan Wyman
Mr. Stevenson Monchery
Mr. Carl Berkowitz
Mr. Matthew Pfisterer, Director
Absent
Mr. Joseph Ruyack, Financial Officer (Excused)
Ms. Marlena Lange, President (Excused)
Visitors
Mr. Jim Moore
A. Roll Call G. Financial Officer's Report
B. Minutes H. Committee Report
C. Visitor Comments I. Old Business
D. Correspondence J. New Business
E. President's Report K. Adjournment
F. Director's Report
III. Discussion and Recommendation
A. Ms. Evelyn Ortega, called the meeting at 5:00pm.
B. Minutes
Ms. Russell moved for the adoption of the September, 2026 regular minutes. Mr. Berkowitz seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-65)
C. Visitor Comments/Staff Report
None
PAGE 2
D. Correspondence
Mr. Pfisterer read a letter of resignation from Board Trustee, President, Ms. Marlena Lange.
E. President’s Report
None
F. Director’s Report
(A copy of the Director’s Report sent to each Board member is attached to the official minutes.) Mr. Pfisterer briefly spoke about the upcoming retirement of our current Principal Account Clerk, Tracy Barretta and our Principal Library Clerk. He extended his thanks and gratitude for their contributions and dedication to the Library.
He also mentioned our new Principal Account Clerk, Luciana Lee.
G. Financial Officer’s Report:
Ms. Russell moved that the regular monthly disbursements for September, 2026 in the amount of $117,024.64 having been audited by Stevenson Monchery and found to be correct, be approved. Mr. Berkowitz seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-66)
2026 Budget Transfer #5
Mr. Berkowitz moved that the Board of Trustees of Middletown Thrall Library accepts the following transfer to cover shortages. Ms. Russell seconded.
To:
L7410.8540.12.0000.5 Repairs and Maintenance $10,000.00
L7410.8514.12.0000.5 A-V Supplies $7,000.00
L7410.8541.12.0000.4 Cleaning/Janitorial Supplies $3,000.00
L7410.8425.12.0000.0 Programs/Adult $1,500.00
L7410.8425.12.0001.0 Programs/Children $3,500.00
L7410.8425.12.0005.0 125th Celebration $150.00
From:
L7410.8200.12.0000.7 Furniture & Equipment $25,150.00
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-67)
H. Committee Report
Building & Grounds: Work on the library’s HVAC upgrades project is scheduled to begin soon. One shelving unit in the children’s room will have to be temporarily taken down until the work is completed.
Work has been completed to replace the worn terracotta ridge caps on the upper roof. There have been no further leaks into the community room.
PAGE 3
H. Committee Report Cont’d
Our exterminating contractor has informed us that we are not currently experiencing any infestation issues currently.
Ms. Ortega moved to go into Executive Session at 5:15pm to discuss contracts.
Mrs. Wyman seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-68)
Out of Executive Session at 5:43pm
Ms. Russell moved to accept the proposal from our Elevator Contractor to repair the elevator at the cost of no more than what is stated. Mr. Monchery seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-69)
I. Old Business
2026 Library Trustee Training
Library’s 125th Anniversary Celebration
J. New Business
Mr. Berkowitz moved the following: Resolved, that the Thrall Public Library District of Middletown & Wallkill Board of Trustees accept the following for the October 6, 2026 Library Budget and Trustee Election. Nareen Russell seconded.
BUDGET VOTE (with absentee ballots) 97 YES 41 NO
TRUSTEES TOTALS: SUSAN WYMAN: 108 WRITE-IN: AL MINGIONE, JEFF BERKMAN
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-70)
Dress Code
November Board Meeting Date: moved from November 11th to November 4th
Board Vacancy
PAGE 4
Mr. Berkowitz moved to go into Executive Session at 5:55pm to discuss the employment history of a particular individual. Mrs. Wyman seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-71)
Out of Executive Session at 5:56pm.
K. Adjournment
Mr. Berkowitz moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:57 pm. Mrs. Wyman seconded.
AYES: Ortega, Russell, Wyman, Monchery, Berkowitz - 5
Nays: None
Motion declared approved. (10/07/26-72)
Respectfully Submitted, Narene Russell, Secretary
TABLE OF MOTIONS
(01/14/26-1) Designated Middletown Times Herald Record Digital Edition official newspaper
(01/14/26-2) Designated Orange Bank and Trust as official bank
(01/14/26-3) Appointment of JBG Law as the HR Personnel Library Attorney & Alex Smith as the Library’s General Attorney
(01/14/26-4) Designation of Financial Audit Firm
(01/14/26-5) Adjournment
(01/14/26-6) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the December, 2025 meeting
(01/14/26-7) Approved monthly disbursement for December, 2025
(01/14/26-8) Unapproved motion to accept Internet Safety Policy
(01/14/26-9) Adjournment
(02/11/26-10) Approval of adoption of the re-organizational minutes for the January, 2026 meeting
(02/11/26-11) Approval of adoption of the regular minutes for the January, 2026 meeting
(02/11/26-12) Approved monthly disbursement for January, 2026
(02/11/26-13) Executive Session
(02/11/26-14) Adjournment
(03/11/26-15) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the February, 2026 meeting
(03/11/26-16) Approved creation by Board of Personnel Committee
(03/11/26-17) Approved 2026 Budget Transfer #1
(03/11/26-18) Approved 2026 Budget Transfer #2
(03/11/26-19) Approved monthly disbursement for February, 2026
(03/11/26-20) Executive Session
(03/11/26-21) Approval of Employee Paid Administrative Leave
(03/11/26-22) Approval to move forward with authorization of LAN Associates to solicit BIDS for the Library’s Defective VAV Boxes and associated work
(03/11/26-23) Adjournment
(04/08/26-24) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the March, 2026 meeting
(04/08/26-25) Approved monthly disbursement for March, 2026
(04/08/26-26) Approval of LAN Associates HVAC proposal
(04/08/26-27) Adjournment
(05/13/26-28) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the April, 2026 meeting
(05/13/26-29) Approved monthly disbursement for April, 2026
(05/13/26-30) Approved 2026 Budget Transfer #3
(05/13/26-31) Approved NYS Annual Report for 2025
(05/13/26-32) Adjournment
(06/10/26-33) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the May, 2026 meeting
(06/10/26-34) Approved monthly disbursement for May, 2026
(06/10/26-35) Executive Session
(06/10/26-36) Approval of LAN’s recommendation of S&O Construction Services for HVAC Project
(06/10/26-37) Approval to pay PT staff shifts during Emergency Closings
(06/10/26-38) Adjournment
(07/08/26-39) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the June, 2026 meeting
(07/08/26-40) Approval to do a Special Meeting on July 29th, 2026
(07/08/26-41) Approval to change the time of the September, 2026 meeting to 5pm
(07/08/26-42) Approved 2026 Budget Transfer #4
(07/08/26-43) Approved monthly disbursement for June, 2026
(07/08/26-44) Approval of Library’s Preliminary Budget for 2027
(07/08/26-45) Adjournment
(07/29/26-46) Approval to hire a new Full-Time Librarian I
(07/29/26-47) Approval to accept both the RCLS Direct Access Plan and RCLS Plan of Service (2027-2031)
(07/29/26-48) Approval to accept the application for the Library Construction Aid
(07/29/26-49) Approval to pay Retro to Part-Time Staff
(07/29/26-50) Adjournment
(08/12/26-51) Adjournment
(09/09/26-52) Opening of the Public Budget Hearing
(09/09/26-53) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the July, 2026 meeting
(09/09/26-54) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the July 29th, 2026 Special Meeting
(09/09/26-55) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the August 12th, 2026 Special Meeting
(09/09/26-56) Appreciation to the staff at the 125th Anniversary
(09/09/26-57) Approved Budget Amendment #1
(09/09/26-58) Approved monthly disbursement for July, 2026
(09/09/26-59) Approved monthly disbursement for August, 2026
(09/09/26-60) Approval of the proposal from our roofing contractor
(09/09/26-61) Closure of the Public Budget Hearing
(09/09/26-62) Approval to accept the Tax Cap
(09/09/26-63) Approval of the Library’s 2027 Budget
(09/09/26-64) Adjournment
(10/07/26-65) Approval of adoption of the minutes for the September, 2026 meeting
(10/07/26-66) Approved monthly disbursement for September, 2026
(10/07/26-67) Approved 2026 Budget Transfer #5
(10/07/26-68) Executive Session
(10/07/26-69) Approval of Proposal from Elevator Contractor for repairs
(10/07/26-70) Acceptance of October 2026 Library Budget and Trustee Election
(10/07/26-71) Executive Session
(10/07/26-72) Adjournment